Apple Jack -- That bill is saying that since we have fire inspections of public schools, we need to have fire inspections of homes used as home schools. Ignoring the fact that the only reason we have fire inspections of public schools, or any building open to the public, is that it is open to the public, ie., to people who have no control over it and need to rely on a third party for assurances of safety. While our home is under our control and we know that we have not blocked the exit or own a fire extinguisher ( or not, point being, we are responsible and it is under our control)
A second California bill has been started that goes further, it is open ended actually, what it wants is to completely re-think homeschooling in CA, ie., do we insist they follow same course of studies as public schools ? Should parents have training ? Should we include mandatory inspections of homes and mandatory medical exams of children ? etc.... says include but not be limited to those three areas....It proposes, as a first step a 2 year committee to discuss and propose "solutions" to those and other undefined areas. Of course, we have no problem, so the whole thing is crazy and vindictive. The unregulated homeschool kids have better outcomes, proportionately, over many metrics, than the public schooled students. Seems to me that the
State should work on getting its own house in order.
I have seen what inspections
can do. I actually know a parent involved with a charter school as a homeschooler, the assigned teacher went to her house to go over the students work (not required, many meet at the library, or choose to not have such oversight at all), anyway, this particular home-teacher told the parent that she could not have a cross on the wall of the dining room, as she was having the child do school work there and that that was a violation of church and state ! ( it is not, of course ) Cant say a prayer of thanks over lunch as that is during school hours.... Your child must read only these state approved books, etc...... they stopped allowing work from a math textbook series I used with my daughter as the author, on the dedication page, said
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
So then I just did not say that we were using a math text at all..... I just teach her math.... but all that garbage only came about for those of us homeschooling under the direction of a public school. The actual independent homeschoolers in CA declare themselves to be very small private schools, and do not have to play such games, until 2 years from now....
It is a very bad way to go to tell families what to do. Especially since there is not some huge problem going on that you can point to to try and say children are being harmed. By any statistical metric, there are not worse outcomes from the un-monitored, non-state textbook users. There are not worse social outcomes, not more abuse, etc.....