It's Americana. We need the abolitionists in the streets at noon but I'm more the type to assist the underground railroad at night.
I do this to blend in with the righties too. I say the Pledge of Allegiance at the gun club even though I think it's sacrilege to pledge fidelity to a piece of cloth much less that it was written by a socialist as a marketing campaign. But for whatever reason the vets love it so keeping them in good graces is fine even if in my heart of hearts they are blaspheming.
Think if you had a child who took biology in college and the prof made them write a paper on the proof there is no God (happened to me). Would you council your child to stand on principle and fail or to tell that poopstain whatever he wanted to hear and keep up the grades and in private keep their beliefs?
If putting a sign in my front yard keeps my house from burning, I'll do it.
lots of good points. I think I would be one who refused to buy sugar and silently supports the abolitionists and maybe quietly give extra food or blankets to the neighbor I know is working the UR. And nullifies the fugitive slave act on a jury.
I am starting to have reservations about the Pledge of Allegiance as well. We had a mom bring it up at our co-op, and I was kind of flabbergasted that someone would object to it on the grounds of what you say. It has made me think, and it is no longer so important to me that my family and my homeschool repeat it. Instead, I have children who have memorized the Preambles to the Constitution and Declaration and the Gettysburg Address and parts of Patrick Henry's most famous speech.
If it were me, I would have found a way to write a paper on how you cannot prove a negative - in other words, I would have written in support that there is a God and dared the professor to fail me. I dared many things like that in college, and didn't get my teaching certificate because of that (Thank goodness - I think I would have hated teaching in a public school!)
---
But then, I grew up on stories of the early Mormon Pioneers and their faith and determination to worship God in the way they thought best.
19-year old Joseph F. Smith, son of Hyrum and nephew of the Prophet Joseph Smith, had this story:
One of the men [in a mob] approached him with a pistol, declaring that it was his duty to exterminate every Mormon he came in contact with. As he pointed his pistol at Joseph, he demanded, “Are you a Mormon?”
Without fear or hesitation, Joseph answered, “Yes siree; dyed in the wool; true blue, through and through.”
The man was so startled by the courage of young Joseph F. Smith that he dropped his pistol and said, “Well, you are the [expletive deleted] pleasantest man I ever met! Shake, young fellow, I am glad to see a man that stands up for his convictions.” The man rode off, with the others following behind (Joseph Fielding Smith, Life of Joseph F. Smith, Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1938, 189).
https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/new-era/1997/11/are-you-a-mormon?lang=engI guess, I just believe that whatever happened in that situation would be for the eternal good of Joseph, so I have carried that over into the rest of my life.
---
but like iam4liberty says - I would rather be in a place where that is not an issue.